Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Rebecca's avatar

In the past two months I read one book by a Nobel Prize winning author and started one by another Nobel winner, both of which I found frustrating. I thought I'd be able to share my frustrations with both of them by now, but alas, the second one is so frustrating that rather than use my precious weekend morning reading time on it, I'm getting through it in 6-10 page increments before I go to bed. My goal for your December post is to have finished that book, plus the "fun" book I'm reading on weekends in its place, AND the play in Russian that I've been working my way through for, literally, years. Stay tuned!

The book I did finish was Tokarczuk's Flights. Here's my beef: Is it just me, or is there a recent trend of calling something a novel when it's really a collection of loosely related stories and musings? Because I feel like I've encountered this with a number of recent works. I'm all for playing around with the standard novel structures and conventions. And I tend to read more for theme, ideas, and writing style, followed by characters and plot. But ultimately I do need characters who stick around for the whole book, and some sort of through line of plot on which to hang the ideas. Is that too much to ask? Anyway! This is all to say that Flights is made up of a narrator's musings about and experiences with travel and also her fascination with studies of human anatomy, alongside stories with themes of travel, or fleeing, and/or human anatomy/ mortality. The musings are anywhere from a paragraph to a couple pages. The stories are longer, well written, and gripping (I was always sorry when a story ended, so there's that). The thing is, there didn't seem to be any sort of progression, and I stopped paying attention to the musings (which I'd say make up over half the book) because there were so many of them coming at me and I wasn't retaining them. Overall it was just too random to stick with me or to give much thought as to an overarching theme. That being said, based on the stories in this book and on Drive Your Plow, I enjoy Tokarczuk's writing and I'll definitely read more of her.

If I were to read one Edith Wharton, which would you recommend?

"We Become What We Worship" sounds like a warning for our current era, or at least it should be!

Expand full comment
Anne Crowe's avatar

I certainly want to read Richard Stark and Lionel White!

Expand full comment
7 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?